Sat, May 25, 2013 /       View Shabbat / Jewish Calendar

JewishBoston.com

Kol Nidre and the Cello: A Snapshot of Teaching Excellence

by Dan Brosgol / September 15, 2010

 

How can you get an 8-year old to understand the depth and emotion of the Kol Nidre service? How does one teach Yom Kippur and Kol Nidre to kids?  These are the kinds of questions that many of us in Jewish Education have struggled with. created at: 2010-09-15

Today at Kesher I was privileged to see a beautiful lesson on this very topic for our 2nd and 3rd grade class.  After a brief framing exercise in which the two teachers led a discussion about the Kol Nidre prayer and its significance, the topic shifted to the music of the prayer, which for many people is its most important feature.

The students watched three clips of the Kol Nidre music being sung- one with a German melody, one with a Russian influence, and an almost haunting Moroccan tune.  The clips are fascinating in their differences and the students watched them with rapt attention.

The students then went upstairs, where one of Kesher’s teachers, who moonlights as a world-class cellist, played Kol Nidrei, Op. 47 for cello, written by a Swiss composer, Max Bruch, who was so moved by the prayer that he composed his own music based on it.  Despite his not being Jewish, the prayer deeply resonated with him and he wrote the music for the cello due to its similarity in tone to the human voice.

The students listened for the beginning of the Kol Nidrei prayer as the notes of the cello echoed through the hall, they engaged in some teshuva reflection as the music filled the room, and they were also asked to draw images that the music was causing them to think about.   After forty-five minutes, the dozen students left class with a much richer understanding of the intersection between music, prayer, and spiritual reflection, and with wonder in their eyes at having experienced something completely new. 

Post Comments

Older Comments

One of my favorite Kol Nidre memories is hearing Kol Nidre being played by a cello. This was at a Brandeis service in the early '80s. Still a wonderful, wonderful memory.

Interesting to read this piece and esp. about Bruch.  Last night, before reading the article, I Googled Kol Nidre and ended up listening to several renditions of Kol Nidre on YouTube.  The cello versions, in particular, blew me away.  As an agnostic, I'm drawn more to the music than the prayer.

Those of you who listen to NPR Weekend Edition last Sunday likely heard an interesting version of Kol Nidre performed by Johnny Mathis.  It's being re-released on an album entitled "Black Sabbath."

Dan,

Fascinating piece about Kol Nidre and children. I think many adults would benefit from the same kind of instruction. What an innovative idea by the teachers.

Linda (Wertheimer)

 

Tags for this Post

Cello Kol Nidre Newton Yom Kippur music

Events

Temple Emanuel of Newton
Saturday, May 25, 2013

Ruach Shabbat Discovery Service

Temple Emanuel of Newton
Electricity in Jewish Law
Sunday, May 26, 2013

Electricity in Jewish Law

The Community Kollel of Sharon
Stroller Walk
Tuesday, May 28, 2013

Stroller Walk

Jewish Community Centers of Greater Boston
Meet the "Ordinary" People of Early Boston with Author Joanne Lloyd
Thursday, May 30, 2013

Meet the "Ordinary" People of Early Boston with Author Joanne Lloyd

Vilna Shul, Boston's Center for Jewish Culture
Community Fun on the Farm Day
Sunday, June 02, 2013

Community Fun on the Farm Day

Jewish Community Centers of Greater Boston
Hebrew 101 - Crash Course
Monday, June 03, 2013

Hebrew 101 - Crash Course

The Chai Center of Brookline
Jewish Community Centers of Greater Boston
Thursday, June 06, 2013

Jews: How We See Ourselves, How We Present Ourselves, How We Are Seen By Others

Jewish Community Centers of Greater Boston
Kabbalat Shabbat Friday Night Services with Meredith Goldstein
Friday, June 21, 2013

Kabbalat Shabbat Friday Night Services with Meredith Goldstein

Havurah on The Hill